“They who assert that a blind fatality produced the various effects we behold in this world talk very absurdly; for can anything be more unreasonable than to pretend that a blind fatality could be productive of intelligent beings?”
- January 18, 1689 – February 10, 1755
- French
- Political Philosopher, Jurist, Author of The Spirit of the Laws
table of contents
Quote
“They who assert that a blind fatality produced the various effects we behold in this world talk very absurdly; for can anything be more unreasonable than to pretend that a blind fatality could be productive of intelligent beings?”
Explanation
Montesquieu rejects the notion that the complex and ordered world, especially the existence of rational human beings, could be the product of blind chance or fatalism. By “blind fatality,” he refers to the idea that events occur without purpose, direction, or intelligence—merely as accidents of nature. He finds this view intellectually unsatisfactory, especially given the presence of consciousness, reason, and moral awareness in human life.
This statement reflects a broader Enlightenment struggle between rational theism and mechanistic materialism. Montesquieu was not a dogmatist, but he did believe that reason itself points toward an underlying order or intelligence in the universe. For him, to claim that intelligence emerged from mindless chaos without any guiding principle was both illogical and contrary to experience. Thus, he argues for a philosophical framework where reason and order imply intention, whether divine or natural.
Today, this quote engages ongoing debates between science, religion, and philosophy. While modern evolutionary biology and cosmology offer naturalistic explanations for complexity and life, Montesquieu’s challenge still resonates: how do we reconcile the apparent randomness of nature with the emergence of conscious, reasoning beings? His insight invites both skepticism of fatalism and a reverence for the rational structures underpinning existence.
Would you like to share your impressions or related stories about this quote in the comments section?
