“It might be pardonable to refuse to defend some men, but to defend them negligently is nothing short of criminal.”
- January 3, 106 BC – December 7, 43 BC
- Roman
- Orator, Philosopher, Statesman, Lawyer, Author
table of contents
Quote
“It might be pardonable to refuse to defend some men, but to defend them negligently is nothing short of criminal.”
Explanation
Cicero draws a sharp moral distinction between choosing not to take up a defense and accepting the role but failing to fulfill it with diligence and integrity. While declining to represent someone—especially if their cause is unjust—might be understandable, to accept the duty of defense and then perform it carelessly is a profound breach of ethical responsibility. Such negligence, he argues, is not just a professional failing, but a moral wrongdoing.
As a renowned orator and lawyer in the Roman Republic, Cicero held the practice of advocacy to the highest standard. He believed that truth, justice, and honor must guide the courtroom, and that those who speak in defense of others—especially in matters of life, liberty, or reputation—bear a solemn duty to act with skill, attention, and honesty. A negligent defense, in his eyes, betrays both the client and the law itself.
In today’s legal and ethical contexts, Cicero’s words still resonate deeply. His insight underscores the principle that responsibility once accepted must be carried out with full commitment. Whether in law, leadership, or any role of trust, to act carelessly when others depend on you is not merely inadequate—it is morally indefensible. Duty, once undertaken, demands competence, effort, and respect for those served.
Would you like to share your impressions or related stories about this quote in the comments section?
