“Democracy… is a charming form of government, full of variety and disorder; and dispensing a sort of equality to equals and unequals alike.”
- 427 BC – 347 BC
- Born in Athens, ancient Greece
- Philosopher, scholar, founder of the Academy
- A student of Socrates, his works include “The Republic” and “The Symposium,” and he had a major influence on Western philosophy with his ideas and philosopher-rulership.
table of contents
Quote
“Democracy… is a charming form of government, full of variety and disorder; and dispensing a sort of equality to equals and unequals alike.”
Explanation
In this quote, Plato offers a critical but acknowledging view of democracy, recognizing it as an appealing system that is full of freedom and diversity. However, he points out that this variety and equality can also lead to disorder and inefficiency, as it treats both equals (those with the same qualities, talents, and abilities) and unequals (those who are less qualified or capable) as if they were the same. In his view, the emphasis on equality and individual freedom in democracy may lead to an imbalance where those who are not equipped to govern or make decisions are given the same power or say as those who are more qualified, creating confusion and instability. Plato warns that this egalitarianism can result in the erosion of meritocracy and the neglect of the common good, as people prioritize personal freedom over the wisdom and virtue needed to govern well.
Plato’s critique of democracy is based on his belief in the need for a philosopher-king—a ruler who is not swayed by popular opinion or personal desires but is guided by wisdom and justice. In *The Republic*, he argues that democracy, while appealing for its freedom and equality, can easily lead to anarchy, where self-interest and disorder replace the pursuit of a just and well-ordered society. This can ultimately give rise to tyranny, where a demagogue seizes power by exploiting the chaos and dissatisfaction created by the democratic system.
In modern contexts, this quote speaks to the tension between freedom and order in democratic societies. While democracy allows for diversity, equality, and individual rights, it can also lead to polarization and inefficiency when equality is applied indiscriminately, without consideration for expertise, wisdom, or the practical realities of governance. Plato’s observation reminds us that true democracy requires careful balance, with mechanisms to ensure that the common good is prioritized and that qualified leadership is in place to guide the society effectively.
