“The test of the artist does not lie in the will with which he goes to work, but in the excellence of the work he produces.”
- 1225 – March 7, 1274
- Born in the Kingdom of Sicily (Italy)
- Theologian, philosopher
- A representative figure of scholasticism, who systematized the relationship between the doctrines of the Catholic Church and reason through his masterpiece, the Summa Theologica
Quote
“The test of the artist does not lie in the will with which he goes to work, but in the excellence of the work he produces.”
Explanation
Thomas Aquinas emphasizes that the true measure of an artist lies not in their intention or effort, but in the quality and excellence of the work they produce. He suggests that while dedication and will are important aspects of the creative process, it is ultimately the outcome—the finished work—that determines the value of the artist’s efforts. Aquinas is highlighting the difference between intention and result. Good intentions alone are not sufficient to judge the success of an artist; it is the mastery, skill, and the impact of the final product that reveals their true talent.
Aquinas, in the 13th century, often sought to articulate the relationship between human effort and achievement in various domains of life, including art. He believed that excellence was not just a matter of internal motivation but also of creating something that reflects beauty, truth, or utility in a meaningful way. In this context, art is seen as a reflection of both the artist’s internal virtues and their skill in shaping their material into something valuable and impactful. Aquinas’s focus on the end result underscores the importance of craftsmanship and the need for artists to strive for excellence, regardless of how sincere their efforts may be.
In modern contexts, this quote is relevant for anyone engaged in creative or productive endeavors. It serves as a reminder that effort and intention, while admirable, must be matched by a commitment to producing high-quality results. Whether it’s in art, writing, design, or even business, the outcome of one’s work is what truly speaks to one’s ability and talent. Aquinas’s insight encourages individuals to focus not only on the process but also on achieving a level of excellence that makes their work stand out and adds value to the world. It reminds us that, while passion is essential, the real test of success lies in what we ultimately produce and how it impacts others.
